18 November 2026
min read

GEMExpert: “Female talent drain in Tech: managers who give more than they receive”

GEM

Committed, but not always recognized: in Big Tech, some women managers perceive they give more than they receive, and blame themselves for their stalled progression. Corina Taban, GEM DBA alumna and former tech executive, unpacks what the psychological contract reveals and what companies can change.

Interview

In the collective imagination, a highly committed woman (manager/executive) is a sign of a well-functioning corporate culture. Your thesis challenges this assumption. Could you explain why?

Corina TABAN: Let’s start with an example that doesn’t come specifically from my research but is well documented: organizational citizenship behaviour. It covers everything people do beyond their role in the company: mentoring others, helping them, taking notes in meetings, organizing an event… Men invest less in this kind of tasks, especially when it is on a voluntary basis, and they do it only as long as they get something out of it: they follow a logic of reciprocity, of “give and take”, if you will. Women, on the other hand, engage in it even when they lack reciprocity. First, because it is an implicit expectation, and they risk backlash if they don’t comply. If you look at the existing research, the risk is real. Second, because they have internalized this expectation themselves: they think it is their duty, and expect to be penalized if they don’t do it.

In my research, I interviewed three categories of women working in Tech: those who want to stay, those considering leaving, and those who have left. I analyzed what they perceived they gave to the company and what the company gave them in return. The most surprising result concerns those who want to stay: they are the ones who feel they receive the least from their company, and yet they are also the ones who feel they give the most. The gap is widest for them: they keep giving a great deal, even when the company no longer gives back something equivalent.

 

You draw on the notion of the “psychological contract” and apply a gender lens to it. How would you define this concept in simple terms, and why is it a good key for understanding women’s career paths in Big Tech?

C.T.: The psychological contract is the set of unwritten beliefs, expectations and mutual obligations between an employee and their employer: what each party believes they owe the other, beyond the formal employment contract. These are subjective and tend to evolve over time.

It’s a good lens because it helps us understand the relationship with the company beyond what is explicit: what women expect from their employer, the trust they place in the organization, whether the processes are fair or not, or whether organizational justice is present. It’s a way of understanding what goes on backstage, in their minds, when they decide whether to stay or leave.

 

You interviewed twenty women in positions of responsibility, currently or formerly working at Big Tech companies, split into three groups: those who stay, those considering leaving, and those who have left. What did this typology allow you to bring to light?

C.T.: Originally, I wanted to identify a trigger that would explain why some leave and others stay. But what this typology mostly revealed was how these women think about their relationship with their work and with their companies.

It was quite surprising. You’d imagine that someone who wants to stay does so because everything is going well. Yet, as I said, those who wanted to stay were often the ones who felt they received the least from their company while giving the most. Conversely, I observed much more detachment among those who had already left.

 

One of your study’s striking findings is that these women tend to overinvest in their role and to internalize responsibility for their own stalled progression. How does this mechanism take hold?

C.T.: I asked them whether their career had been influenced by their gender. Most of the time, the answer was “no”, especially among those who stayed. To explain their stagnation, they blamed themselves: they didn’t take up enough space, didn’t master office politics well enough, didn’t speak loudly enough.

Yet these behaviors were coded as “typically masculine” by the interviewees themselves. It’s because they didn’t adopt these behaviors that they believed they weren’t progressing. This implies that the company rewards “typically masculine” behaviors. But these women blamed neither their gender nor their company: they blamed themselves for not adopting these behaviors that they identified as the key to moving up.

 

You describe the “Golden Cage” phenomenon, where women in positions of responsibility stay in their jobs for financial security, despite a gap between what they give and what they receive. What does a woman in this situation actually experience, and did you identify in your interviews a trigger that makes some of them suddenly tip toward a definitive break?

C.T.: The golden cage is specific to the Big Tech environment I studied, known for its high salaries and benefits. The notion is present among all these women, whether they are still in their jobs or have already left. If you think it’s worse elsewhere, the psychological contract stays strong, even if you’re not entirely satisfied. Many felt they were treated better than their peers in other sectors or former colleagues , which makes the decision to leave even harder.

For those who stayed, the picture was clear: the package was good enough to keep them in the company and the sector, even though they would have liked to explore other horizons, expressed some dissatisfaction, or felt they were giving more than they received.

The trigger is most visible among those who have decided to leave but are waiting for the right exit. They were very clear that the problem they perceived came from the company, not from them. The benefits were excellent, but not enough to balance out everything else anymore: the golden cage no longer counted. Their gap between what they give and what they receive was, incidentally, smaller than among those who want to stay.

For those who had already left, there was no single moment that marked the breaking point. Context played a bigger role: the French tech sector was then offering attractive, well-paid voluntary departure packages. They seized the opportunity to leave on good terms.

 

In your work, you show that HR policies claiming to be “gender-neutral” miss a specific mechanism: that of a psychological contract that is, itself, gendered. Should HR and People Leaders change the way they assess performance to take this into account?

C.T.: Society is not neutral and companies are a reflection of society. You therefore can’t have completely “equitable” companies as long as society itself is not equitable.Nonetheless, companies remain the economic backbone of our society: they therefore have the power to move social norms forward. I’ve made several recommendations for HR leaders and, more broadly, for organizational leaders.

My first recommendation is making advancement expectations explicit, transparent, and available. The women interviewed often said that, to move up, they had to adopt “masculine” behaviors, which fed their guilt when they failed to do so. To address this, companies can define objective advancement criteria based on performance rather than personality, and train managers to distinguish style from the quality of work.

The second recommendation is to reduce the legitimacy tax. Organizations push women to overinvest in proving their legitimacy. This stems from a lack of diverse role models in leadership. Companies should promote different leadership styles, measure success by results, and better distribute non-promotable tasks (organization, note-taking, events, managing other people’s emotions), including  teaching women to say no, and managers to distribute these more equitably.

The third recommendation is to reduce ambiguity around unfairness, including through pay transparency by role and career equity specialists, trained and available for consultation in case of doubt.

Lastly, addressing reciprocity gaps, through manager-employee discussions around what one gives and receives respectively. If imbalances appear, the organization can look for structured ways to resolve them accordingly.

 

Your approach is part of an engaged research tradition (Engaged-Activist Scholarship). What does this change in the way you share this research today?

C.T.: This is something that matters a great deal to me. I am a woman, and I believe women should have access to the same opportunities as men. When women are allowed to fulfill their potential, it would benefit everyone: beyond morality, it makes economic and social sense. And that is valid for women today as well as for future generations.

Conducting this research was for me a way to commit. Today,  I share this research through conferences and discussions. Last year, I received a Best Doctoral Paper award from the Management Consulting division of the Academy of Management, at the annual conference in Copenhagen. I think it’s essential to have a practical dimension, with concrete recommendations, and that can be put in action by organizations.

 

If the Human Resources department of a tech company could retain only one thing from your thesis in order to act, what would it be?

C.T.: There are extremely competent, intelligent and committed women who negotiate their psychological contract downward, because they have other responsibilities (personal, as mothers or wives) and because society puts a lot of pressure on their shoulders. These women invest enormously, but they scale back what they expect from their company. If companies do nothing to counter this trend, they have a lot to lose in terms of potential.

Publication

Reopening the debate on the psychological contract of women in big tech companies

Corina Taban and Séverine Le Loarne.

https://journals.aom.org/doi/10.5465/AMPROC.2025.18548abstract 

More on Corina Taban’s research : https://www.corinataban.com/leadership-and-organizational-change

Bio Express

Corina Taban

Corina Taban is an organizational behavior researcher and CEO of 934 Advisors, a consultancy that helps organizations prepare their workforce for AI adoption. Recognized as a Next Generation Female Leader by McKinsey, she previously led strategic content and data licensing partnerships for Microsoft and Meta across several international markets.

Corina successfully defended her doctoral thesis this year as part of her Doctorate in Business Administration (DBA), and is now an alumna of the program. Her award-winning research focuses on the evolving employment relationship, leadership dynamics, and organizational adaptation in fast-moving environments.

Today, she advises, trains, and works with C-level executives and senior leaders on how organizations adapt and evolve at the intersection of strategy, technology, and human behavior.

Author
GEM team